Doctor Who #797: The Poison Sky

"This isn't war, this is sport."
TECHNICAL SPECS: First aired May 3 2008.

IN THIS ONE... The Sontaran poison the sky, the Doctor burns it.

REVIEW: Knowing the episode wasn't very good, I tried very hard to find things I liked in it. As with Part 1 of this story, it's the small character moments that tend to shine. Except there are fewer of them to make room for the plot, Martha is an evil clone for most of it and thus gets fewer moments, and what's there is often redundant and doesn't tell us anything new. But we still get a reference to the Brig. An "are you my mummy?" joke. Sylvia showing some of that practicality Donna has. Donna refusing to get sentimental when she gets her TARDIS key. Wilf being Wilf and Donna having a hard time leaving him again. Donna fighting aliens with a small rubber mallet. Skorr's "wonderful" death in battle. The Doctor so quickly disarming Luke and throwing away his gun. Donna slapping the Doctor before clinging to him, relieved he hasn't died. But even in this department, there are clunkers. Martha's clone going all Blade Runner with her "all that life" line. Colonel Mace and his subaltern sharing a stagey kiss when the world is saved. These don't really work.

Like the plot, frankly. The whole idea of the Sontarans creating a cloning farm out of the Earth is fine, and for once, we can believe the effects would be up to the challenge of showing a clone army (there are lots here already), and smoking up the place in "clonefeed", that works too. What doesn't work is the solution to this problem. The Doctor makes a machine that might as well be MAGIC. It shoots a ball of fire into the sky, which starts a fiery chain reaction that covers the entire world in flames, yet leaves no after-effect. It apparently burns just the Sontaran fumes and nothing else, leaving clear blue skies. Despite the fact that the fumes are mostly ground based, which would mean the fire should have spread lower and at least singed the lawns. And covering the whole planet despite the fact there can't possibly have been a whole lot over the oceans. No collateral damage from burning the atmosphere up. MAGIC. The same gadget, when used on the air inside the Sontaran vessel, obliterates the ship, which is just as ridiculous. Burn the air inside a metal structure should make it explode and disintegrate. But before we get to that, we get the least believable sequence in the episode (if not Series 4). The Doctor volunteers to sacrifice himself by taking the fire-gun to the warship himself. The companions are giving him better ideas (like put the thing on delay) and I could add one more (if you want to "give them a chance", how about calling them somehow?), but his goodbye scene would be manipulative if it was even remotely possible he could die here. It isn't. Even worse is that Luke Rattigan, a complete sociopath who sold the human race out so he could experiment with eugenics on another planet with less than a couple dozen people (who, at least, prove not to be sociopaths themselves), has a change of heart and sacrifices himself in the Doctor's stead. I'm sorry, no. It might have been bolder for the show to have Martha die for the Doctor here, but it would at least have made sense. Another pass at the script, and the Martha clone could have been the one. Luke? Nope. It was him because he was the only disposable character in the room, and that's bad writing.

Less integral to the plot, but just as ill-considered, is the death of Ross Jenkins. The kid deserved a recurring role, not a meaningless death just to make the Doctor angry. Like it was needed?! The Sontarans massacre UNIT and Mace still doesn't listen to the Doctor, which at one point, just makes him look foolish. When the Valiant arrives, which is treated like this big punch-the-air moment, it just reverses the massacre so that UNIT can kill all the Sontarans in much the same way. Why is the Doctor happy about this exactly? It feels wrong. And the questions. Why is Staal so contemptuous of females when the Sontarans don't have males either? What's the bit about the Martha clone being turned into a triple agent? Doesn't quite make sense. I think you get the picture: It's not a good script.

REWATCHABILITY: Medium-Low - There are a number of nice little moments, but the emphasis is definitely on "little". The plot runs on complete nonsense, which unforgivably extends to the Doctor being out of character.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

The only way I can make sense of the Doctor being so ready to sacrifice himself is that it was the ol' Survivor's Guilt rearing its head again, as once more he prepared to destroy a hostile alien armada. But when you have to go fishing for motivations to justify bizarre character behavior, it's probably bad writing. That, or "Hamlet". (Ba-zing!)

Siskoid said...

Don't. Don't-Don't do that.

Anonymous said...

Apologies, I had no choice, none whatsoever. (Though you will notice that I said it's bad writing OR "Hamlet", so "Hamlet" isn't a form of bad writing.)

As far as "Hamlet" goes, my opinions are no doubt cartoonishly simplistic compared to yours, but my take on it is, Shakespeare got it right -- if Hamlet is behaving in erratic fashion in parts, it's because he's become somewhat unmoored from a sense that there is a basic order and justice to things. It's not a character making peculiar choices to prop up a bad plot, it's a character making the sort of choices that just might be natural under the circumstances.

 

Blog Archive

Category

5 Things to Like (21) Activities (23) Advice (74) Alien Nation (34) Aliens Say the Darndest Things (8) Alpha Flight (25) Amalgam (53) Ambush Bug (46) Animal Man (17) anime (52) Aquaman (70) Archetypes (14) Archie Heroes (10) Arrowed (20) Asterix (9) Atom (30) Avengers (58) Awards (33) Babylon 5 (140) Batman (677) Battle Shovel (13) Battlestar Galactica (134) Black Canary (22) BnB 2-in1 (40) Books (60) Booster Gold (16) Buck Rogers (11) Buffy (6) Canada (70) Captain America (69) Captain Marvel (55) Cat (156) CCGs (50) Charlton (12) Circles of Hell (6) Class (11) Comics (3958) Comics Code Approved (12) Conan (15) Contest (13) Cooking (15) Crisis (77) Daredevil (33) Dating Kara Zor-El (5) Dating Lois Lane (23) Dating Lucy Lane (13) Dating Princess Diana (11) DCAU (404) Deadman (9) Dial H (128) Dice (10) Dinosaur Island (16) Dinosaurs (67) Director Profiles (9) Doctor Who (1676) Doom Patrol (22) Down the Rabbit Hole (7) Dr. Strange (17) Encyclopedia (28) Fantastic Four (56) Fashion Nightmares (19) Fiasco (14) Films Within Films (6) Flash (83) Flushpoint (86) Foldees (12) French (49) Friday Night Fights (57) Fun with Covers (56) FW Team-Up (37) Galleries (9) Game design (26) Gaming (111) Geekly roundup (762) Geeks Anonymous (47) Geekwear (13) Gimme That Star Trek (60) Godzilla (53) Golden Age (431) Grant Morrison (75) Great Match-Ups of Science Fiction (8) Green Arrow (50) Green Lantern (87) Hawkman (39) Hero Points Podcast (13) Holidays (241) House of Mystery (15) Hulk (44) Human Target (8) Improv (34) Inspiration (45) Intersect (5) Invasion Podcast (44) Iron Man (50) Jack Kirby (87) Jimmy Olsen (74) JLA (94) JSA (25) K9 the Series (30) Kirby Motivationals (18) Krypto (202) Kung Fu (98) Learning to Fly (11) Legion (129) Letters pages (6) Liveblog (12) Lonely Hearts Podcast (21) Lord of the Rings (18) Machine Man Motivationals (10) Man-Thing (6) Marquee (89) Masters of the Universe (9) Memes (39) Memorable Moments (35) Metal Men (5) Metamorpho (65) Millennium (72) Mini-Comics (5) Monday Morning Macking (7) Movies (457) Mr. Terrific (6) Music (73) Nelvana of the Northern Lights (8) Nightmare Fuel (21) Number Ones (59) Obituaries (41) oHOTmu OR NOT? (76) Old52 (11) One Panel (290) Outsiders (165) Panels from Sheena (5) Paper Dolls (7) Play (76) Podcast (487) Polls (5) Questionable Fridays (13) Radio (18) Rants (20) Reaganocomics (8) Recollected (11) Red Bee (26) Red Tornado (10) Reign (563) Retro-Comics (3) Reviews (52) Rom (116) RPGs (539) Sandman (21) Sapphire & Steel (37) Sarah Jane Adventures (70) Saturday Morning Cartoons (5) SBG for Girls (4) Seasons of DWAITAS (100) Secret Origins Podcast (8) Secret Wars (25) SF (30) Shut Up Star Boy (1) Silver Age (368) Siskoid as Editor (34) Siskoid's Mailbox (10) Space 1999 (51) Spectre (20) Spider-Man (100) Spring Cleaning (15) ST non-fiction (19) ST novels: DS9 (8) ST novels: S.C.E. (19) ST novels: The Shat (2) ST novels: TNG (9) ST novels: TOS (13) Star Trek (1711) Streaky (2) Suicide Squad (38) Supergirl (89) Superman (1060) Supershill (11) Swamp Thing (23) Tales from Earth-Prime (7) Team Horrible (4) Teen Titans (83) That Franchise I Never Talk About (53) The Orville (29) The Prisoner (5) The Thing (54) Then and Now (4) Theory (51) Thor (52) Thursdays of Two Worlds (43) Time Capsule (8) Timeslip (7) Tintin (23) Torchwood (62) Tourist Traps of the Forgotten Realms (5) Toys (65) Turnarounds (7) TV (193) V (6) Waking Life (1) Warehouse 13 (9) Websites (102) What If? (103) Who's This? (203) Whoniverse-B (11) Wikileaked (3) Wonder Woman (82) X-Files (246) X-Men (102) Zero Hour Strikes (25) Zine (5)