RPG Talk: Planned vs. Improvised

GameMasters are often praised, and themselves moan, about their preparation. Players need just come to the gaming session, but GMs, ahh, they've got all this work to do beforehand.

Or do they?

It really depends on a number of factors. I've personally run the gamut. I've set up elaborate scenarios, written scene by scene, for all probable eventualities. I've taken notes as I read and adapted pre-fab adventure modules. I've drawn maps and made props... But I've also tried improvising entire sessions, starting play with a single question: "Ok, what do you want to do?" and taking off from there.

Obviously, the prepared approach feels safest, but there's something extremely pleasurable in flying by the seat of your pants, hands free. But it's not for every game.

Game complexity is one factor that should be taken into account. While in some games, it's really easy to stat up an opponent on the fly, others require a steadier balancing act, and perhaps too much diving into rule books to truly support the flow of an improvised session. My best improvised experience was with GURPS, which shows it's possible, but I did either have stats for possible characters on hand, or else pulled books that featured pre-fab characters and used their stats as quick guidelines (you can always stat the character up properly after play).

More important, I think, is the focus of the game. Some games are about PLOT - a dungeon delve, a detective investigation - and these do require some prep if they're to be coherent, even if a real maverick could definitely pull it off. If the focus is principally on character interaction, improvisation becomes easier, particularly so in sedentary games that use a single location and cast of NPCs. When asked what they want to do, the players will have those touchstones to orient them, and the GM will too, building on what has gone before, not exactly inventing a whole world without forethought.

But of course, the GM HAS forethought. A game may be improvised, but the GM's been thinking about the game world all week. As have the players, who are granted additional agency when such an approach is taken. "What do you want to do?" could have any answer, but the group is really building the story together; it's not just the GM's affair.

Ultimately, a mix of the two approaches is probably best. Improvise where you can, but also give the players big set pieces that you did, in fact, prepare. You might spend entire sessions without a road map, interacting with NPCs, building the relationships between PCs, hinting at what might be (prepared) over the horizon. And then there's a proper mission, someone asks for help, and the heroes journey to that dank cave where fate (that's you) has something in store for them.

Point is, when you work without a net, you allow the players and the world to breathe and perhaps INSPIRE the next big thing. And it gives the GM more time (always at a premium, that old commodity) to prepare the bits that NEED preparation. The balancing act between character and plot is usually done over the course of a single session, and guess what, character usually loses out to plot. Play that over the course of several sessions, and you're giving character more of a shot.

Lead to one of my most satisfying gaming experiences and so I render it to you here...

So, what kind of GM are you? Do you thread this particular needle?


Anonymous said...

As a GM I feel pretty uncomfortable running games under prepared, but comparatively capable of thinking on my feet. By my own admission I NEED to do some decent research/preparation before running historical games in particular, even if I know most of that work will ultimately go to waste. I often feel 'authenticity' ultimately gets in the way of players feeling comfortable to inhabit their characters and interact with the historic world at large, anyway. Further deconstructing planning, I often feel besides making the GM feel generally more comfortable, planning is often the springboard for improvisation. That established background allows the GM to have thought deeper about the raw mechanics of the scenario and ways it can teased out in various directions on the fly. One other thing, I generally only have a vague idea of a solution to the plot in mind. Having a fixed solution often closes down room for improvisation, and puts pressure on the GM to take control of events to lead to a 'successful' outcome. Besides, the ultimate aim is to make the player's feel ingenious, so why not go with their solution ultimately. Finally, I think a good follow up article might look further at planning. So, just what is worthwhile and what isn't? I get the feeling even experienced GMs waste time doing things that ultimately are more about stroking one's ego than about practical planning.

Siskoid said...

I like that! I'll put it in my thinking hat and see what comes out.

After I proved to myself that I didn't need to plan out every inch and second of an adventure, I did a lot of gaming where I would plan out the beginnings of scenarios, and let the players dictate where it would go and how it would end. My Doctor Who "seasons" were a lot like that.


Blog Archive


5 Things to Like (21) Activities (23) Advice (74) Alien Nation (34) Aliens Say the Darndest Things (8) Alpha Flight (25) Amalgam (53) Ambush Bug (46) Animal Man (17) anime (54) Aquaman (71) Archetypes (14) Archie Heroes (10) Arrowed (20) Asterix (9) Atom (31) Avengers (59) Awards (33) Babylon 5 (140) Batman (680) Battle Shovel (13) Battlestar Galactica (134) Black Canary (22) BnB 2-in1 (40) Books (61) Booster Gold (16) Buck Rogers (24) Buffy (6) Canada (72) Captain America (69) Captain Marvel (59) Cat (156) CCGs (63) Charlton (12) Circles of Hell (6) Class (11) Comics (4004) Comics Code Approved (12) Conan (15) Contest (13) Cooking (15) Crisis (78) Daredevil (33) Dating Kara Zor-El (5) Dating Lois Lane (23) Dating Lucy Lane (13) Dating Princess Diana (11) DCAU (404) Deadman (9) Dial H (128) Dice (10) Dinosaur Island (16) Dinosaurs (67) Director Profiles (9) Doctor Who (1693) Doom Patrol (22) Down the Rabbit Hole (7) Dr. Strange (17) Encyclopedia (28) Fantastic Four (56) Fashion Nightmares (19) Fiasco (14) Films Within Films (6) Flash (87) Flushpoint (86) Foldees (12) French (49) Friday Night Fights (57) Fun with Covers (56) FW Team-Up (37) Galleries (9) Game design (26) Gaming (111) Geekly roundup (774) Geeks Anonymous (47) Geekwear (13) Gimme That Star Trek (61) Godzilla (53) Golden Age (448) Grant Morrison (75) Great Match-Ups of Science Fiction (8) Green Arrow (50) Green Lantern (88) Hawkman (40) Hero Points Podcast (13) Holidays (241) House of Mystery (16) Hulk (44) Human Target (8) Improv (34) Inspiration (45) Intersect (5) Invasion Podcast (44) Iron Man (50) Jack Kirby (88) Jimmy Olsen (74) JLA (97) JSA (26) K9 the Series (30) Kirby Motivationals (18) Krypto (203) Kung Fu (100) Learning to Fly (11) Legion (131) Letters pages (6) Liveblog (12) Lonely Hearts Podcast (21) Lord of the Rings (18) Machine Man Motivationals (10) Man-Thing (6) Marquee (89) Masters of the Universe (9) Memes (39) Memorable Moments (35) Metal Men (5) Metamorpho (65) Millennium (72) Mini-Comics (5) Monday Morning Macking (7) Movies (459) Mr. Terrific (6) Music (73) Nelvana of the Northern Lights (9) Nightmare Fuel (22) Number Ones (60) Obituaries (42) oHOTmu OR NOT? (82) Old52 (12) One Panel (305) Outsiders (167) Panels from Sheena (6) Paper Dolls (8) Play (78) Podcast (510) Polls (5) Questionable Fridays (13) Radio (16) Rants (20) Reaganocomics (8) Recollected (11) Red Bee (26) Red Tornado (10) Reign (563) Retro-Comics (3) Reviews (52) Rom (116) RPGs (541) Sandman (23) Sapphire & Steel (37) Sarah Jane Adventures (70) Saturday Morning Cartoons (5) SBG for Girls (4) Seasons of DWAITAS (100) Secret Origins Podcast (8) Secret Wars (25) SF (30) Shut Up Star Boy (1) Silver Age (371) Siskoid as Editor (36) Siskoid's Mailbox (10) Space 1999 (51) Spectre (21) Spider-Man (100) Spring Cleaning (15) ST non-fiction (19) ST novels: DS9 (8) ST novels: S.C.E. (19) ST novels: The Shat (2) ST novels: TNG (9) ST novels: TOS (13) Star Trek (1734) Streaky (2) Suicide Squad (39) Supergirl (90) Superman (1065) Supershill (11) Swamp Thing (24) Tales from Earth-Prime (7) Team Horrible (4) Teen Titans (85) That Franchise I Never Talk About (54) The Orville (29) The Prisoner (5) The Thing (54) Then and Now (4) Theory (51) Thor (52) Thursdays of Two Worlds (43) Time Capsule (8) Timeslip (7) Tintin (23) Torchwood (62) Tourist Traps of the Forgotten Realms (5) Toys (65) Turnarounds (7) TV (193) V (6) Waking Life (1) Warehouse 13 (9) Websites (102) What If? (104) Who's This? (215) Whoniverse-B (11) Wikileaked (3) Wonder Woman (84) X-Files (246) X-Men (103) Zero Hour Strikes (28) Zine (5)