data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7f8d3/7f8d3d0b9e4c5887d6f797a7c662b098489ae671" alt="Ho!"
Archie: In the Golden Age, Black Jack was a policeman who was kidnapped, escaped and went underground to become a "mystery man". It's an intriguing way to set up a secret identity! For some reason, most of his villains have card-inspired names: Poker Face, Black Seven, "Deuces" Wilde... He was never very popular and his feature in Zip Comics was given over to the Web. Interesting because...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1ac72/1ac72a1af7d4c4321f1ec2122b51ca723fac04d7" alt="Parobeck scores"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9309e/9309e3252142f50451a0b78d4f01d391469b64a4" alt="Nice shorts Bob"
Archie: The Golden Age Bob was a gossip columnist who frequently ridiculed the police by day, the same way he showed them up by night as a superhero with unexplained ghostly powers. Also in the unexplained file: Why he called himself Bob when his actual name was Walt. Perhaps because he's so campy, Bob has a lot of fans out there, so expect his name to fill many blogs and letters pages in a future near you.
Impact: This revival traded on the silliness of his name and made him the assistant associate producer of a news station trying to get an interview with the Comet by posing as a superhero, and later to stalk heroes full time. All existing shots of him apparently have him falling all over himself. It takes more coordination to be a hero than we sometimes realize. I do think we're now ready for a "serious" hero called Bob Phantom though. I do.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b750f/b750f5bb278e05304937fa0e3da8b436d5bd2ff1" alt="Volt: Graduate of the Stormtrooper Academy"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bcdf0/bcdf0c5f803f4182d4e99bec39167707e4c06d3e" alt="Ho!"
Archie: There was a very obscure character called Captain Commando, basically a soldier who put on a costume to get lead Allied forces in battle. The other Archie Captain is Captain Flag: Effete playboy Tom Townsend's father is killed before his eyes, but before he can do anything about it, an eagle crashes through the window and flies him out to its aerie where it cared for him. That, along with the mountain air and an American flag brought to the nest had the same effect as a super-soldier serum on him. Maybe DC could use him as the new Black Condor? Maybe not.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/96236/9623663d090356a052e161b3b7779348c690f622" alt="Ho ho ho! :-S"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ed852/ed852985b81d0ea344ec25d6b27262aad42e0872" alt="I have a friend called Fireball"
Archie: Here's a guy who could control and absorb flames, dedicated to fighting crime and in particular, arson (he's a fireman in real life). DC apparently acquired him too late to save the Martian Manhunter. The Golden Age costume looked a lot like the original Blue Beetle and not very "fiery".
Impact: This version of the character discovered the fireballs of a Native American legend in a swamp and followed them back to a rift in spacetime. A visit to the other side endowed him with fiery powers and he teamed-up with the Fly soon afterwards. This Fireball fared better than the original, getting to star as the token "I don't have my own title" character in the Crusaders team book.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/20752/20752455904eeb0eef3f219da3ce631aede95e2a" alt="They need that tan"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/58577/585770d7dc53746c2c69c84bf41a124de7089051" alt="Now with stealth logo"
Impact: One of the heroes least changed as far as looks go, this Fox was instead a Native American (Apache) ecological terrorist and a human/fox hybrid (who can fly and heal others... FOXY!). Environmentalist heroes rarely, if ever, work, probably because people don't like being preached to, so a revamp might do away with it. However, I'd love to see a superhero that hangs out in nature instead of the usual urban landscapes.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3f809/3f809c5df523bf4c77576ee22b13ad741a579ae7" alt="See, it says no dumping here"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8a81a/8a81a91309550cf8e30160ebfbbee83c20d9d3d0" alt="Is he choking... himself?"
Archie: The Comet's brother who took a name and costume when his brother died, he spent his days inside the pages of Pep Comics choking criminals to death. Yeah! He even had his own comic for a bit. Though the kind of horrifyingly violent stuff that would play well in today's market, Archie's all ages direction has kept him under wraps for decades (the 1983 comeback didn't do a thing for him).
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e709d/e709d07e907748b426bc194c0c043cf761cf5889" alt="Spooooooky"
INFERNO
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4e97d/4e97d6ab9779d9708a2e152296b0cae5d462659b" alt="Disco Inferno"
Impact: The 90s weren't kind to Inferno. His name was repurposed for an armored menace who fought the Comet in a number of issues. He used to be a patriot who let the military turn him into a cyborg, but the computer controlling his actions went a little HAL 9000 on him. Something similar was done with jungle hero Kalthar the Giant Man, who consumed magic grains that gave him powers, whose name was more or less borrowed by interdimensional monster Kalathar in Impact Comics. I'm not sure what the point was (same size, I guess).
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0e34c/0e34cc75be7d6e2c81747245b05f048735926261" alt="Wrong way!"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a0778/a0778e82ea6524401034665c554d6277440005f7" alt="Man of Steel"
Archie: If being dipped in steel doesn't kill you, it'll make you super, like Mr. Sterling here. He was a fairly popular feature in the Archie line-up, but wasn't really picked up by Impact (see below). His place in comics history is assured thanks to his nickname: Man of Steel. Yep, Superman is a big thief. Especially now that they might be in the same universe!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fce73/fce73ae75425d4379e906c71da6ea598c9007427" alt="Man of Mercury"
FIREFLY and other AMERICAN CRUSADERS
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2eed3/2eed3c7f275ba711923eb7cab6c860fa1578405e" alt="Is that supposed to be a bug?"
Impact: Impact's Firefly actually does something with the "fire" part by giving a flamethrower. Not all gimmicks have to be fancy. The team also features a Doc Savage kind of character called Doc Strong, a possible allusion to Private Strong, a flag-themed hero by flag experts Simon & Kirby. Sorceress-later-turned-villainess the Black Witch is probably alluding to Archie's terrifying Madam Satan, who enticed men to commit crimes, then killed them, accumulating souls for her master. Wow.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8055d/8055da4768d0dde6abe191a670070b327386e984" alt="Kill the ground!"
Among the heroes Impact never got to reinterpret, we find:
-The Wizard: Archie's first, if I'm not mistaken, a sort of masked Mandrake type.
-Zambini Miracle Man: If the Wizard was Mandrake/Zatara, Miracle Man was Sargon the Sorcerer. Or maybe that's Kardak. How many heroes with turbans did Archie have anyway?
-Hercules: Technically, the Greeks invented this one and the Romans retconned him.
-The Falcon: AKA The Press Guardian who protected the integrity of journalism. Marvel stole his name, and Grant Morrison kinda made sure a newspaper-themed Guardian's been done already.
-Mr. Justice: Archie's Spectre analog was 11th-century prince who haunted a castle until it was dismantled by the Nazis. His archenemy? Satan himself.
-Mr. Satan: Would you begrudge Madam Satan a boyfriend? Actually, there's no relation. Just another Satanic-sounding character from the good people who brought you Betty & Veronica Digest.
-Red Rube: A Captain Marvel rip-off, he shouted "Hey, Rube!" to become an adult superhero (it's apparently the carny's battle cry). Instead of lightning, it was a tornado. Instead of working in radio, he worked in the papers. Instead of making sense, he was pretty stupid.
-Scarlet Avenger: Think Crimson Avenger, but using super-science. His story was something of a tragedy, losing his family and the muscles required to smile in a plane crash.
Does DC own them all? Does it need to? That's not for me to say. I might have missed some too. We'll soon see, won't we?
Comments
The !mpact Black Jack had a really nice design. One of the reasons I buy reference material for defunct lines like !mpact is to check out concepts and costumes that could be repurposed. The color scheme makes me think Parobeck himself carried over elements of Elongated Man he liked while on that mini-series.
I like the idea of a super-hero openly critical of police. That's different. Not a bad costume on the original, either. It seems like both the !mpact Captain Commando and Fireball borrowed from it. Captain Commando really did have a great look for a soldier, for more practical than patriotic colors, or even Snake-Eyes all black.
I'm surprised the Fox didn't amount to more, but I'd have to blame the name myself. There's only so many jaguars, but just take a look at a Wiki disambiguation for "fox." Oy!
The 40's Hangman stories really looked fantastic, but he's never had a good costume in my estimation. That !mpact revision sounds terrible. Enough with the damned injuns already! Was there a single black, Latino or Asian !mpact hero? Oh yeah, my favorite, but besides Jaguar...?
Minority representation is low in the line, with white men taking up the bulk of it (maybe proportionally higher than standard DC or Marvel fare, maybe not).