data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bcb0e/bcb0e12a937345fc5e8d54ec4e1c9466e2ac349a" alt="Some fine looking men"
And my heart is only big enough for one of them!
FIGHT!!!!
Titles
"Greatest of the Spaceknights" vs. "Quark's idiot brother"
Advantage: Rom
Rom in the Bedroom
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/34bbf/34bbf4c9b9fdc103d2d048a05fa9c2b5f3c5e7c7" alt="Gulp!"
Advantage: Rom
The Ex
Shala-Bal... sorry, I mean Ray-Na vs. Prinadora: On one side, the girl Rom left on Galador and who died at the hands of the Dire Wraiths, lighting the candle he would hold in his heart for her for 200 years. On the other, a shrewish naked Ferengi female and Nog's deadbeat mom.
Advantage: Rom
The Nasty Brother
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/89298/8929812c17ea8ce9b6f2b3f44142558b37097eb9" alt="Anything for the Bajoran Orphan Fund"
Advantage: Gotta be Rom.
Hideous appearance
Penlight eyes, no naughty bits, eerie blank expression, mittens for hands...
Big bumpy head, teeth that would scare any orthodontist, hunched posture, giant ears that might as well be phalluses...
Advantage: Rom, definitely.
Wikipedia Disambiguation
Who comes first? I thought so: Rom.
The grand winner: ROM!!!!
Was there ever any doubt?
Comments
I don't know much about the spaceknight version, though looking at the early comic a few days back seemed to paint a portrait not seen in the rest of the Rom based comics.
I do know Rom went through some changes during the start of DS9 though (gruff idiot who can't fix a replicator to affable idiot who invents replicating mines).